One of the most challenging professional development tasks is helping teachers improve the questions they ask students.  Teachers are aware that some questions require students to think more meaningfully, yet research shows that these questions are rarely asked.  “About 60% of teachers’ questions require students to recall facts; about 20% require students to think; and the remaining 20% are procedural.” (Gall, 1970)  These percentages are not surprising because it takes practice and patience for teachers to develop questioning skills.

The problem that happens during professional development was that teachers could reflect on their questions after a lesson, but they couldn’t go back and see how a modified question would have resulted.  It was with this in mind that we developed the professional development tool called Questioning Scenarios.  This activity begins with teachers in groups of three taking the roles of teacher, student, or observer.  The individuals playing the role of teacher and student each receive a slip of paper describing their corresponding scenario.  An example is shown below:

Teacher

You want to find out what answer your student got to the question, “What is the area of a square with a side length of 4?”  Determine what conceptual understanding the student has by asking questions, especially questions that encourage elaborated responses.

Student

You are working on finding the area of a square with a side of length 4.  You are confusing finding the area of a square with finding the perimeter of a square.  As such, to get your answer you count all the sides of the square and get an answer of 16.  You are proficient in addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division.

The individuals playing the role of teacher and student get time to read their paperand learn their roles.  Meanwhile, the individual playing the role of observer is waiting to record all of the teacher’s questions to the student.  Once the activity begins, the teacher will talk to the student in the context of the scenario described on the slips of paper.  A possible interaction for the scenario above is:

Teacher: “What is the area is of a square with a side length of 4?”

Student: “16.”

Teacher: “Great.  Does that make sense?”

Student: “Yes it does.”

This interaction may seem common for most mathematics classrooms.  The teacher asked a question to which the student responded with a correct answer.  The teacher checks to see if the question makes sense to the student and the student replies that it does.  However, consider this slightly different interaction:

Teacher: “What is the area is of a square with a side length of 4?”

Student: “16.”

Teacher: “Great.  How did you get that answer?”

Student: “The square’s sides are all 4 long so I added them together and got 16.”

When the teacher changed the question from “Does that make sense?” to “How did you get that answer?” responding with “Yes it does.” was no longer a sufficient answer.  The student was forced to explain his or her thinking.  In this case, asking a question that encouraged an elaborate response allowed the teacher to uncover a misunderstanding that may have otherwise gone unnoticed.  Having students explain their thinking is one of the simplest and most natural forms of assessment in the mathematics classroom.

A complete write up about the Questioning Scenarios activity can be found here.

Additional teacher and student scenarios for use during Questioning Scenarios professional development can be found here.

References:

Gall, Meredith D. “The Use of Questions in Teaching.” Teacher Education Division Publication Series (1970): 713.

1. Jen says:

I wonder what your thoughts are on this problem. While I agree that having Student explain their thinking is imperative, I also think this is a poor problem to begin with. Would you actually use this in class or is this more of a hypothetical to explain why questioning is important?

• Robert Kaplinsky says:

Thanks for the question, Jen. I never use Questioning Scenarios with students. I only use them with teachers as part of professional development.

2. Cara Hetrick says:

• Robert Kaplinsky says:

Interesting way to break that down. I think I used to ask for answers but now care more about how they got the answers.

3. Amber Uidenich says:

Thanks, I’m going to share this with my fellow teachers this week! After reading this article, I had a similar interaction in my class where the student’s answer for #1 seemed right but when I asked about the #2 that was wrong, I saw #1 was a lucky wrong answer and it was such an aha moment for me!

4. Joanne Caniglia says:

I love this approach. I teach future teachers and this will be so helpful!

• Robert Kaplinsky says:

Thanks Joanne.